Anatomical 3D visualization: Scanning bones to reconstruct the appearance of people and animals
A recent addition to the forensic reconstruction toolkit at the University of Dundee, Artec’s Eva and Space Spider 3D scanners help scientists advance their research.
How much like us did our human ancestors and ancient people look? That’s a question artists and scientists like Caroline Erolin and Dr Christopher Rynn from the University of Dundee, Scotland are trying to get answers to. Caroline and Christopher specialize in anatomical 3D visualization and can reconstruct the appearance of a deceased human based on their skull bones.
Archaeological facial reconstruction is in high demand among museums and documentary film makers. Most recently the face of “Thankerton Man” was reconstructed for the Biggar and Upper Clydesdale Museum in Scotland. Found in a stone cist in the Scottish village of Thankerton in 1970, the skull was radiocarbon-dated to between 2460 BC and 2140 BC and thought to have been that of a man aged 18 to 25.
“Thankerton man,” reconstructed at the University of Dundee. Image courtesy of the BBC
Caroline and Christopher’s work is not limited to archaeological facial reconstruction alone. They actually run MSc’s in Medical Art and Forensic Art and Facial Identification at the University’s Centre for Anatomy and Human Identification (CAHID). They work with policy-makers and are actively involved in medical and forensic casework and facial identification, providing evidence to the UK criminal justice system.
The Centre recently turned to Patrick Thorn & Co., Artec’s UK Gold Partner, to purchase an Artec Eva 3D scanner together with an educational package, as part of the Centre’s move to upgrade its current methods of imaging.
Patrick himself installed the Artec system and conducted a one-day comprehensive training course on it and the capabilities of Artec Studio 3D scanning and post-processing software. His visit to CAHID happened to coincide with the one of a BBC documentary crew, who filmed an episode about facial reconstruction with Christopher for the “Inside Out” program, which covers regional stories and investigations throughout the UK.
A still of Dr Christopher Rynn talking the viewers of the BBC’s “Inside Out” program through the facial reconstruction process. Image courtesy of the BBC
“So far the scanner has been a great hit with the students, who amongst other things are learning forensic facial reconstruction techniques to aid in the recognition of unidentified human remains,” says Caroline Erolin. “The students practice their skills on casts of skulls taken from CT [computed tomography] data of living individuals rather than live cases. However, we now can scan skull bones as well.”
The reconstruction process involves rebuilding the facial anatomy upon the skull. This can either be done in clay upon the cast or digitally modelled onto a scan in the computer. Caroline says that there are a number of advantages to working on a scan: it doesn’t damage the actual skull and once digitized, the layers of the reconstruction can be viewed and modelled independently. Once completed, the final facial reconstruction can be compared to the face of the living individual.
One piece of coursework involves reconstructing the facial muscles in wax to create a detailed and lifelike anatomical model. This piece helps teach the students both facial anatomy and sculptural skills in advance of working on the reconstructions described above. A number of students have used Artec Eva to scan their models and create digital versions that can be shared and interacted with online using Artec’s Viewshape site and other 3D model galleries.
Scan of MSc Forensic Art student coursework (depicting a yawn) in Artec Studio.
Another project CAHID’s staff are involved with is digitizing the D’Arcy Thompson Zoology collection. The University’s Zoology Museum houses many fascinating specimens from around the world. The collection can be browsed online. Most of the specimens were collected by the celebrated Sir D’Arcy Wentworth Thompson, the first Professor of Biology at Dundee and author of the influential 1917 book ‘On Growth and Form.’
The hope is to make the collection more accessible to everyone, including the general public and local population as well as staff and students. Once scanned the intention is to create a virtual online museum where 3D models of specimens can be viewed and interacted with. Some will also be 3D printed so they can be handled at open days and taken to schools.
Caroline scans a gorilla skeleton at the D’Arcy Thompson Zoology Museum.
“Many of the specimens are quite complex and require multiple scans from different angles,” Caroline says. For example, a skull usually requires at least two scans, one for the ‘top’ surface and another for the ‘bottom.’ There may be more if the mandible is scanned separately.”
Scan of a Walrus skull from the D’Arcy Thompson Zoology Museum, made with Artec Eva.
“Skulls can be tricky objects to scan as they contain so many intricate details and concavities,” Caroline adds. “However Eva seems to be able to capture most of these details well. It helps that the scanner is so portable, as it can be taken into the museum for scanning on site with the aid of the Artec battery pack and our laptop. The texture capture of Eva is excellent and exports well for use in other 3D software such as ZBrush.”
Showing a group of students how easy it is to use the Artec solution.
Following up on their successful experience with Artec Eva and cooperation with Patrick Thorn, CAHID have purchased an Artec Space Spider to enable the capture of smaller and more detailed specimens. Plus combining the larger scans of Eva with Space Spider’s finer detail is a perfect solution for the Centre’s specialists.
“It will also allow us to teach our students a wider range of 3D scanning techniques from large specimens such as elephant skulls down to the smallest juvenile osteology samples,” Caroline says. “Previously we used more basic laser scanners that did not capture the same levels of detail or any color texture, which was a limiting factor for us. 3D scanning has never been more affordable and easy to perform than it is now.”
A scan made using Artec Eva, of an adult skull having undergone cranial binding from CAHID’s skeletal collection.
CAHID’s plans include digitizing its extensive skeletal collections, including the Scheuer Collection of juvenile osteology. The Scheuer Collection is believed to be the only active repository for juvenile skeletal remains held anywhere in the world. It consists of the remains of over 100 sub-adult individuals, collected from archaeological and historical anatomical sources. Many of these specimens are very fragile and handling them is highly restricted. By digitizing the collection they will become accessible to students online visually and also as 3D printed specimens for use in class.
From industrial design to manufacturing to healthcare or CGI, with Artec scanners, ‘impossible’ is a word that we have little reason to use.
When a scanner is used on a moving body, it receives conflicting spatial coordinates, so instead of a homogeneous shape, a three-dimensional “motion blur” is the result. In this case, digitally capturing the horses as perfectly as possible was a must.
If you hear about something unexpected surfacing in Australia, no one would blame you for first thinking about some kind of wily mammal making its way into town, or an alarmingly large spider that you’d be better off leaving alone. In this case, the surprise came in the form of a boat.